Skip to main content

"Cold Justice" Heats Up Unsolved Murder Cases

This is my third blog post on TNT's new reality show, "Cold Justice".  Cold Justice pairs former Texas prosecutor Kelly Siegler with former Las Vegas CSI Yolanda McClary, who travel to small rural towns across America to look at unsolved murder cases.  Their first episode which aired Tuesday has already delivered results - the arrest of Ronnie Hendricks (see yesterdays post for details) for the murder of Pam Shelley. TNT lists an episode guide online, and 
I couldn't resist taking a peek and looking for details on those cases.  I was astonished at what they have accomplished in their first season.  This is more than just another crime drama, these ladies are committed and determined to bringing justice to those who may have escaped it previously in small towns that may lack the resources to bring a suspect to trial.

You can see the episode guide on their website. They give a brief description of the victims and circumstances of their deaths. Here is a list of this seasons cases:

Episode 2) Victim:  67 year old Mattie Williams was found stabbed and bludgeoned to death in the woods outside of an abandoned house approximately 4 miles from her home on 8/28/06.  Williams lived in Morehouse Parish, LA and was said to be an active member of her church and a loving mother. Her daughter, LaShonda Williams told reporters how difficult life was without her mother during a 2008 interview with a local reporter. She also stressed how the family leaned on each other for strength after the killing. Williams was initially believed to be missing, after a friend went to her home and saw blood outside of her house and called the police.  Her body was found just 6 hours later.  This episode runs next Tuesday, and it appears Siegler and McClary may have breathed new life into this cold case.

On 7/2/13, reported there were 3 people indicted for second degree murder in relation to this case.  All three face mandatory life sentences if convicted.  Sadly, one of the three is Mattie Williams' own son, John Williams. This episode airs next Tuesday on TNT.

Episode 3) Victim:  32 year old Eric Baxter, who was found shot to death in his home in Dickson, Tennessee on 8/20/98.  This is said to be the only unsolved homicide in the small community where it occurred. I haven't been able to find any additional information on the circumstances around his death, possible suspects or the outcome of Siegler and McClary's investigation.

Episode 4)  Victim: 17 year old Rachelle Escalante was believed to have been killed by a hit and run driver on 7/6/88 in Globe, Arizona.  Escalante was said to have been walking home from a party when she was struck.  Escalante had just completed her junior year in high school when she attended a party with friends where a fight broke out.  Escalante left the party on foot, and patrol officers came across her crawling across the middle of the road - they initially believed it was an injured animal but as the got closer they realized it was a young girl. They stopped their patrol car and attempted to help her, but it was too late. I was unable to find any additional information on this investigation online. Guess I'll have to wait until the episode airs!

Episode 5)  Victim: 48 year old Charlene Corporon was found shot to death in her home in Palacios, Texas on 6/6/82. Corporon owned the most successful agricultural business in town and worked with her son Gary. It was widely known that Gary had been physically and verbally abusive towards his mother in recent years, and when a friend of Charlene's knocked on the door looking for her, Gary answered reportedly said "Charlene doesn't look too good". She had been shot in the head with a .22 caliber gun.  This is by far the most perplexing of the cases/episodes so far. The episode guide gives little information on this case, but what I found online makes this a mystery. In a May 4, 2012 article in the it says that Charlene's son Gary was charged with murder but may never be tried. The issue at hand seems to be this:  was he ever indicted for this murder, and if he was indicted and charged, why hasn't there been a trial? Gary Corporon is said to be working offshore near LA and remains free on $100,000 bail.  OK, if he's free after posting bail, that would indicate that he WAS arrested wouldn't it? It's confusing. Some law enforcement officials say he had been arrested, some aren't so sure. District Clerk Becky Denn said there was no record of Corporon's indictment. What gives here? District Attorney Steven Reiss told the Houston Chronicle reporter that he planned to ask a new grand jury to "re-indict" Corporon, he further stated that "the delay does not appear to have been created by any law enforcement agency". He has requested additional investigation into the improprieties which appear to have caused a 31 year delay in prosecuting this case. South Texas College of Law professor Geoffrey Corn believes Corporon has a great case for a "speedy trial dismissal".  There is no statute of limitation on murder, but what happens if Corporon was arrested 30 years ago, and never brought to trial - and the charges were never dropped? What if the ball was dropped entirely? If there is no record of the indictment, what could the bail bondsman tell us about this issue? 

The circumstances around Gary Corporon's freedom were brought to light after Kelly Siegler began investigating the case for a Cold Justice episode. Nubbin Chambbe, a former Sheriff's Detective who worked this case back in 1982 said he was told that Corporon was not indicted, and that the grand jury "passed" on the case, wanting additional information. So is that where the ball was dropped?  Matagorda County Sheriff Douglas "Skipper" Osborne declined to answer questions on the case because it is a pending case. Sam Hurta, who was Sheriff in the early 80's and former DA Jack Sayler were unavailable for comment on the case. This will be another episode I'll have to watch to see what they uncover. Was Gary Corporon ever arrested back in 1982? Has he been living free of consequences for 31 years, after being a strong suspect in his mother's murder? 

Episode 6) Victim: 29 year old Mary Ann Holmes was a single mother living in the small mostly Mormon community of Thatcher, Arizona when she was found handcuffed, tortured, raped and sexually mutilated in her own home. Her two small girls witnessed the murder, and the 3 and 5 year old girls were also tied up and naked. The oldest girl managed to free herself and ran across the street to a neighbor/friend's house for help. It was too late, Mary Ann Holmes was dead, and it appeared her 3 year old was covered in her mother's blood. It was reported that one of the girls said "mommy was hurt by a lion-man". Holmes had a yard sale in the morning, and the money she made from the yard sale was missing. Police believe someone at the yard sale may have come back later that evening. Police initially interviewed more than 75 people about this case, but no suspect emerged. Holmes' ex boyfriend was an early suspect after police noticed Holmes had filed a report, believing he was en route to Arizona from Florida. Although Holmes feared him, the ex-boyfriend's alibi checked out according to investigators. Little evidence has been disclosed, but there was a bloody shoe print, said to be size 11 1/2 found at the scene. There may have also been a single finger print on the handcuffs used on Holmes. What an awful murder, and for some animal to do that in front of two innocent children is just unfathomable. I really hope they find this guy.

Episode 7)  Victim:  49 year old Isabel Corale was found dead on the couch in her Fremont, Ohio home on 1/24/88.  It appeared that the mother of six fell asleep on the couch and in the early morning hours, somebody hit her in the head with an object. She never woke up.  She was discovered the following morning by her husband, who called police. When police arrived, Corale's husband and three of her children were upstairs, frightened and covered in blood. A hatchet was found propped against a wall in the home - was it the murder weapon? I was unable to find any additional information on this case, or the outcome of Siegler and McClary's investigation.

Episode 8)  Victim: 54 year old Robert Bryant was found beaten to death on the floor of the Agriliance Fertilizer Warehouse in Seagrave, Texas where he worked for 26 years. His body was discovered by a fellow employee. Bryant was known as a reliable employee who always arrived early and started the coffee. He was well liked and the community was shocked at this crime. Bryant's wallet was found with money inside, still in his pocket.  Little else is known about this case. Was he killed by another employee, or did he interrupt a robbery?  I can't find anything else on this case online.  I'll have to watch the episode!

Those are the episodes listed thus far.  Very interesting to see what can happen when new eyes look over these cold cases. Even though there has only been one episode so far, I really like this show.  This seems much different from "The First 48", "Dateline" and "48 Hours".  I think the chemistry between Siegler and McClary is great - they are both well respected in their fields - and I like the detective they are using, named Johnny Bonds. He's known to be a master interrogator. Looks like at least 3 of the 8 cases now have arrests to go with them.  Not bad!


  1. Gee, I wonder where you are getting your so called facts. You might want to check their authenticity before you go posting half truths. (Ep. 6)

    1. Anonymous (9/6 @ 9:29)
      I'd be happy to tell you where I got the INFORMATION. TNT has a Cold Justice website, where they have an episode list that gives background on each case. I then looked for news online on the cases. Why the sarcasm?

    2. Anon (9/7)
      Information on Mary Ann Holmes murder

    3. Sorry, that eyeroll is for the original nasty commenter, not you MyForte.
      -- a-z

    4. I'm sorry, but what's the big whoop about this episode??? Who says these women heated up ANYTHING? Kelly said she met with the D.A. who told her HE is going to seek another indictment. Where in the episode did the D.A. say ANYTHING about these two women having anything to do with him seeking another indictment? Notice how the D.A. didn't even appear in the episode, nor did he thank these women for doing ANYTHING!!! Tell me why I shouldn't think this episode was a total hour of bull crap? Tell me which part I missed that these two women had anything to do with the D.A. seeking a new indictment. SPIN, SPIN, SPIN. To me it's worse than Nancy disGrace telling us that she loves making a difference...LOL, LMAO!!!!!

    5. Anonymous (9/17 @ 10:19PM)
      If you don't like the show, don't watch it. I'll tell you where Siegler made a difference - she found new witnesses that went fishing w/Gary Corporon 2 weeks before his mother was killed and saw him with a .22 caliber. The 1982 grand jury indictment wasn't even known until the new sheriff decided to look at cold cases and Cold Justice got involved.

  2. MyForte, first, thanks for your blog. Next, I am very impressed with this new show and am eager to see the next installment. The Corporon case that aired tonight was a shocker! Next, I wish the interwebs would make people be nicer rather than nastier, but it's not working that way so far. I strongly suspect the anonymous snarklet is by a teenager who is not fully cooked. I hope people like me help make up for people like him/her. Cheers,

    1. Your idea of a shocker: A D.A. saying that he's going to seek another indictment, WITHOUT saying anything that these two woman had anything to do with that, and nothing about if he made that decision before they even looked into the case. And no resolution after the hour about anything.

    2. Anonymous (9/16 @ 10:23PM),
      I think it's shocking that a 31 year old murder indictment was uncovered due to a new sheriff looking at cold cases and the involvement of Kelly Siegler and Cold Justice. Siegler uncovered new witnesses who can put a .22 caliber gun in Corporon's hands just 2 weeks before his mother was killed.

    3. Anonymous (9/17 @ 9:09PM),
      Thank you for your comments. I like this show and appreciate that these 2 women care enough about these unsolved homicides go out and get involved. I think they would be just as happy doing this without a show involved, but it's interesting to watch their process. And yes, people like you make up for the people who just like to post negative stuff on other people's blogs! I could delete their comments, but everyone is entitled to their own opinion. Thanks for your post!

    4. You're welcome MyForte. Sincere and well argued dissenting opinions should be well tolerated by bloggers, I agree. It's when they attack other commenters, the blogger, and ruin the discussion with their antics that their opinion loses ground against the validity of the opinion of others. But maybe it will be bored soon and move along. Ciao, --a-z.

    5. A-Z,(9/18 @ 8:29PM),
      Thankfully the good people who leave comments here far outweigh the few who leave negative ones. This is America and we all have the right to our own opinions. I've only deleted a handful of comments over the course of this blog - and those were remarks about Alyce LaViolette during the Jodi Arias murder trial. I didn't feel her sexual preference was a topic that needed to be discussed in this forum! Thank you for your comments.

  3. Even if they brought nothing 'new' to the table they got the DA to review the old case information which showed he had been indicted for the murder. They made the case public again and hopefully the DA can get to the bottom of what happened before. People need to find better things to do besides criticizing everyone else all the time, I hope they are criticized as much by others.

    1. Anonymous (9/18 @ 5:33PM),
      Well said! Whatever it takes to breathe new life into these cold murder cases, even if that means doing so on television. It's my understanding that the whole concept behind the series is to look at unsolved murder cases in small rural towns across the country, where resources weren't available. Sure, TNT is hoping the series draws in viewers and makes them money. But I get the feeling Siegler and her team are in it for the victims, not the show. Just my opinion! Thanks for your comment!

  4. I am very enjoyed for this blog. I feel strongly about it and love learning more on this topic. If possible, as you gain expertise, would you mind updating your blog with more information? It is extremely helpful for me
    We provide zealous representation for our clients from intake throughout trial. If you find yourself in need of legal representation, do not hesitate to contact our office Houston Criminal Defense Attorney

    1. Sajib,
      I'm glad you like the blog! I just started posting on Cold Justice because there were no big trials in progress after Jodi Arias'. I love Cold Justice, I'm a big fan of Kelly Siegler. I post updates after the show, and try to follow the cases afterwards as well. I'm impressed with the results they have had! Thank you for stopping by and commenting.

  5. I lived in the house that maryanne Holmes was murdered in the mid 2000's while going to eac for a few years...growing up in the gila valley this case has bothered me for a long time..shotty police work ruining the crime scene, letting the dna evidence get ruined in a storage unit...glad to hear this case is getting the attention it guess is glen rogers did it..just a hunch.

    1. Josh,
      Wow, how interesting that you lived in that same house and are familiar with the case. Are you talking about the serial killer Glen Rogers? I'm not yet familiar with the known suspects of this case/episode. Thank you for leaving your comments on this case. You definitely have a unique viewpoint, coming from that area.

  6. Do you have any further news about the Marisol and Baby murder that showed on Cold Justice? Did they indict her boyfriend and/or his 2nd pregnant girlfriend at the time? What can we do to get tv back in the courtroom? Miss it! ;-)

  7. I just watched the Corporon case on Netflix. The text at the end stated that the new Grand Jury came back with "no decision."

    So, nothing was accomplished? It's almost worse than before, because now there was "no decision" from the GJ, where before they actually indicted. Right?


Post a Comment

Thank you for commenting!

Most popular posts

Dr. Janeen DeMarte - A Look At The Prosecution's Expert Witness

Dr. Janeen DeMarte is expected to take the stand in the Jodi Arias murder trial as a key witness for the prosecution. Think of DeMarte as the State's response to Dr. Richard Samuels and potentially Alyce LaViolette. It's unclear when DeMarte will testify, but with Alyce LaViolette's testimony wrapping up, I thought it would be helpful to take a look at who the State's expert witness is.

Dr. Janeen DeMarte is a licensed clinical psychologist who has a private practice in the Phoenix area. She holds a master's degree and PhD in clinical psychology. with a concentration on forensics - and graduated from Michigan State University and fulfilled her doctoral residency at Arizona State Hospital.  Her clinical training was done at outpatient clinics, correctional facilities and inpatient unit settings. She has served as the Clinical Director of a large outpatient behavior health clinic in Phoenix and "oversaw the practice of numerous multidisciplinary treatment provide…

Is Alyce LaViolette Cashing In On Murder Trial?

As the defense finishes questioning their star witness, domestic abuse expert Alyce LaViolette, many are disillusioned by her choice to take the stand to portray murder defendant Jodi Arias as a battered and abused woman.  Maybe I'm the one who's crazy, but wasn't Travis Alexander the one who had the life stabbed, slashed and shot out of him at the hands of Jodi Arias? Who battered whom here?  Are Travis Alexander's not-so-kind text messages to Jodi Arias PROOF that he was a womanizing batterer and bully who held all the power in the relationship between Arias and Alexander?

Alyce LaViolette seems to think so. Does she have any idea the feelings of outrage she is bringing out in the hearts and minds of the real victims of domestic abuse all over the country? Before LaViolette began testifying, I kept asking myself "why would a woman who is so well respected in her field choose THIS case, defend THIS woman?"  Could it be the money? I suppose $250-$300 an hour c…

Was Trip to Cancun Catalyst to Murder? Jodi Arias Murder Trial

Marie "Mimi" Hall was the first prosecution witness to take the stand in the Jodi Arias Murder trial. She took the stand on January 3, 2013. Hall told jurors that she met Travis Alexander through the Mormon Church. Although they initially went on a date, it was quickly recognized that they were a great match as friends, and they remained such good friends that Alexander invited Hall to accompany him on a work retreat to Cancun, Mexico. The trip was to begin on June 10, 2008. Travis wouldn't live to see that day. Friends found him murdered in his home in Mesa, AZ on June 9, 2008. Coincidence, or catalyst? Travis's close friends have told investigators that Arias had been engaging in stalker-like behavior in the months preceding the murder. Twice, Alexander had his tires slashed after going out with other women. He told close friends his Facebook account had been hacked into. Arias even reportedly would use the doggie door to gain entry to Alexander's home. …

A Look At Alyce LaViolette And More Strange Video Footage of Arias Arrest

Yesterday, as Dr. Richard Samuels finished up his testimony the Jodi Arias defense team called their next expert witness to the stand, Alyce LaViolette. LaViolette is a very legitimate expert on the subject of domestic violence, having been one of the early leaders back in the 1970's when this was not a topic that was spoke of often. Jennifer Willmott had LaViolette introduce herself and her educational background, and list her many accomplishments helping battered women and even helping the men who battered them, hoping to return these women to a safer environment. She is likable, and she is a legitimate voice on this topic. The prosecution should not expect this witness to be as sloppy in the trial casework and reporting as Dr. Samuels was. 

While it's unknown exactly how far out on a limb LaViolette will go for Jodi Arias, she is expected to testify about some of the characteristics of battered women, why they return to their abusers - and what some of characteristics are of…